Claws Seafood Market

Love love love !!! The staff was super friendly we ordered the double lobster roll and I think it’s probably one of the best ones I’ve ever had it was so worth it ! The oysters were huge ! It’s definitely being added to my list of go to places ! And of course I had to grab some salmon from the market to make the next day for dinner it was great !!

Cool spot in Sayville. Has a cool outdoor dining area with a little creak embedded. Food was pretty good. We had lobster rolls, fish and chips , New England clam chowder and lobster bisque. Only things I’d say is I wish they put more butter or Mayo, however they make it, when mixing the lobster claws. It lack a bit of something. And the lobster bisque had too much liquor, overpowering the lobster flavor. Fish and chips and New England were excellent! Staff was super friendly and efficient. Food came out fast. Parking ez out front. Prices are decent, good portions of food! Def recommend giving it a try!

Great local spot that is becoming more and more popular. Have dined here 4 times already. The prices have gone up but that is expected in COVID times. Ordered the delicious pan seared tuna encrusted with black sesame with a wasabi glaze and soy sauce. Was made perfectly. Very delicious and for $12 it was a very good deal. All served over a bed of seaweed salad. Also ordered the Buffalo shrimp for $10. Nice big and fresh shrimp. The Buffalo was perfect spice level. Came with a side of blue cheese which was a hit with me as I love Buffalo wings. Also ordered the classic lobster roll with a side of fries for $30. Lobster roll was fresh with big chunks of lobster. Perfect lobster salad inside of a toasted bun. A leaf of lettuce inside to just hold it together and give it that crunch when biting down. The only disappointment was the lobster bisque. It was not even hot. Very bland. No seasoning in it. Seems like it was taken out of a bag and microwaved for a couple of seconds. Check the pictures Also btw. It’s right next to a creek and ducks come by to have some crackers or fires. Order at counter and sit outside and enjoy.

My husband and I came here twice. First time because they were the only seafood market that opened later than 5pm. Prices were about normal. The second time was to try their hot cooked seafood. The food was really good and seasoned well. Their soups are really good as well. The young man who helped us was nice. The only bad thing that had me traumatized was the bathroom(porta potty). It was like it never been clean sooooooo disgusting( I closed that door super quick and put my entire bottle of hand sanitizer on) it shouldn't be nowhere near the eating area. Had me talking to myself. Like you know damn well you should have never tried to peek or thought to go inside.

The market has lots of variety and the lobster rolls are outstanding. Don’t order the onion rings because they no longer offer those (that’s what we were told after the took our order for them…) but the fries, hush puppies, and the sweet potato fries are yummy. The rolls aren’t great but the lobster salad and the naked lobster is tasty!!

First time visiting this location to try the lobster rolls. Must say, I was impressed. The double ‘Naked’ roll was portioned perfectly and the lobster was fresh and tasty. particularly liked the layer of lettuce that adds a crunch on each bite. The stuffed clams (2 for $5.95) was very reasonably priced and tasted great. same goes for the fried clams. This is a great lunch spot with lots of outdoor seating. The service is fast with a great selection of local beers. Will be back! Highly recommended!